When it comes to indulging in the quintessential New York City burger experience, SoHo stands out as a culinary hotspot. Among its myriad dining options, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer has carved a niche for itself, offering a harmonious blend of gourmet burgers and artisanal milkshakes. As a food blogger dedicated to uncovering the best burger in SoHo NYC, I embarked on a flavorful journey to explore what makes Black Tap a must-visit destination for burger aficionados.
A Glimpse into Black Tap’s Origins
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer was established in 2015 by restaurateur Chris Barish. Drawing inspiration from the classic American luncheonettes of the 1950s, Black Tap was born out of a desire to elevate the humble burger into an art form. The name “Black Tap” is a nod to the iconic black tap handles found in craft beer establishments, a reflection of the brand’s commitment to offering high-quality brews alongside its gourmet fare.
Located at 529 Broome Street, Black Tap’s SoHo location serves as a flagship for the brand. It exudes a chic yet laid-back vibe, complete with graffiti-inspired wall art, neon signage, and upbeat music, making it an inviting spot for locals and tourists alike. The SoHo outlet perfectly encapsulates the energetic and artsy character of the neighborhood.
The Star of the Show: Black Tap’s Burgers
At Black Tap, burgers are treated as more than just a meal—they are an experience. With a menu that caters to traditionalists, adventurous eaters, and vegetarians, every burger is crafted to perfection using fresh, premium ingredients. Here are some standout options:
- The All-American Burger: A timeless classic, this burger is topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and the restaurant’s signature special sauce. Served with a side of golden fries, it’s an ode to classic American comfort food.
- The Texan Burger: For those seeking bold flavors, this burger packs a punch with crispy onion rings, bacon, cheddar, and a smoky BBQ sauce that ties it all together.
- The Greg Norman Burger: A half-pound of Wagyu beef, house buttermilk-dill sauce, blue cheese, and arugula combine to create this award-winning creation. It’s a burger that exemplifies luxury in every bite.
- The Vegan Burger: Even plant-based diners can rejoice at Black Tap. This burger features a falafel patty topped with vegan feta, pickled onions, and creamy hummus, all wrapped in a vegan bun.
Each burger comes with the perfect pairing: a mountain of crispy French fries, seasoned to perfection. Black Tap’s emphasis on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients is evident in every bite, making their offerings stand out in the bustling food scene of SoHo.
The Accolades Speak Volumes
Black Tap is no stranger to awards and recognition. It has received numerous accolades, including the prestigious “People’s Choice Award” at the NYC Wine & Food Festival’s Burger Bash for its Greg Norman Burger. This winning streak has firmly established Black Tap as a contender for the best burger in SoHo NYC.
More Than Just Burgers: The Milkshake Marvel
While the burgers are undoubtedly the star attraction, Black Tap has gained international fame for its milkshakes, particularly the CrazyShake® line. These towering creations are Instagram gold, with elaborate toppings that transform a simple milkshake into a work of edible art.
Some of their most iconic CrazyShakes® include:
- The Cookies ‘N Cream Supreme: A rich cookies-and-cream shake with a vanilla frosted rim, crushed Oreos, and a cookies-and-cream sandwich perched on top. It’s a sugar rush in the best way possible.
- The Cake Shake: A whimsical masterpiece featuring a slice of funfetti cake, rainbow sprinkles, whipped cream, and a cherry—all on top of a luscious vanilla shake.
- The Sweet ‘N Salty: For those who love a mix of flavors, this shake combines peanut butter, chocolate, caramel, and pretzels, topped with a peanut butter cup and a chocolate-dipped pretzel rod.
These milkshakes aren’t just drinks—they’re experiences that evoke childhood nostalgia with a contemporary twist. Paired with one of their gourmet burgers, the milkshakes create the ultimate indulgent combo.
The Craft Beer and Cocktail Scene
Black Tap’s commitment to delivering a holistic dining experience extends to its drink menu. The bar offers a curated selection of craft beers from local and international breweries. Whether you’re into crisp lagers, hoppy IPAs, or rich stouts, there’s something for every beer lover.
For those who prefer cocktails, Black Tap’s mixologists whip up creative concoctions that complement the food menu. Popular options include the “SoHo Mule,” a zesty blend of vodka, ginger beer, and lime, and the “Cherry Cola Old Fashioned,” which adds a playful twist to a classic favorite.
Why Black Tap Stands Out in SoHo
SoHo is home to countless eateries, but Black Tap stands out for its dedication to quality and innovation. Here’s why it’s a cut above the rest:
- Diverse Menu: From award-winning Wagyu burgers to indulgent CrazyShakes®, Black Tap caters to every craving.
- Atmosphere: The vibrant, artsy décor and lively music make it a fun and welcoming space for all ages.
- Location: Situated in the heart of SoHo, it’s a convenient stop after exploring the neighborhood’s boutique shops and art galleries.
- Accessibility: With options for vegetarians, vegans, and those seeking gluten-free alternatives, Black Tap ensures no one feels left out.
Exploring SoHo Before or After Your Meal
Black Tap’s location in SoHo offers the perfect opportunity to combine a delicious meal with an exploration of one of NYC’s most vibrant neighborhoods. Here are some nearby attractions to check out:
- Dominique Ansel Bakery: Famous for the Cronut®, this bakery is a must-visit for dessert lovers.
- The Drawing Center: An art museum dedicated to drawing, it’s a hidden gem for culture enthusiasts.
- Shopping on Broadway: From high-end boutiques to unique local shops, SoHo is a shopper’s paradise.
A Foodie’s Verdict
After savoring Black Tap’s expertly crafted burgers and whimsical milkshakes, it’s clear why this eatery has become synonymous with the best burger in SoHo NYC. The attention to detail, from the quality of the ingredients to the playful presentation, elevates the dining experience to something truly memorable. Whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker or a visitor exploring the city, Black Tap is a destination that delivers on its promise of indulgence and innovation.
